PM’s India Visit To Reset Ties
YUba Nath Lamsal:
Prime Minister Balendra Shah is scheduled to visit India next week at the invitation of his Indian counterpart, Narendra Modi. This is his second foreign visit and his first bilateral visit since he assumed the premiership in March 2026. His first official foreign trip was to the USA in September this year to address the 81st UN General Assembly, where he emphatically raised the climate change issue and its devastating impact on the Himalayas.
PM Shah’s India visit is being viewed by foreign policy watchers and even the general people with much curiosity and optimism. Foreign policy watchers and others are curious as to what exactly PM’s India visit would bring about and what issues are likely to be raised and discussed in his New Delhi sojourn. As most of the visits of our heads of government to India in the past had stirred criticism and controversies back home, PM Shah’s slated visit is also being viewed with high caution about which the prime minister has to be cautious.
Nepal and India are close neighbours bound by geography, history, culture, social values, civilization, river systems and economic engagements. They are so closely inter-connected and have a nature of relations that hardly exists between any other two countries in the world. Nepal and India also have a common perspective on many issues in the international forums. Yet they have divergent positions on some areas.
Harmonious ties
Countries are said to be prisoners of geography. Geography, to a large extent, shapes the nature of relations between countries. Nepal is a landlocked country surrounded by India on three sides-- east, west and south-- and by China in the north. Geography has, thus, created a compulsion for Nepal to manage and maintain friendly and cooperative relations with India. Now India is a rising economic power and, according to the World Bank, it lifted over 500 million people out of poverty in the period between 2011 and 2023 and has drastically reduced abject poverty from over 27 per cent to less than 3 per cent. Nepal should learn and take advantage of India’s experiences and economic upsurge, for which harmonisation of relations is necessary. India, too, needs to understand the fact that harmonious relations and close cooperation with Nepal is in its own interest.
Nepal and India also have several issues and disputes, which is natural for countries sharing a border and having multiple engagements. The more engagements countries have, the more issues and disputes they encounter. These issues range from territorial disputes, trade, water and its benefit sharing, cross-border crimes, air routes, security matters and provisions of some old treaties. These issues have led to occasional hitches in the relations between these two closest neighbours. Nepal faced four economic blockades from India in the past that created a kind of scepticism about India in the minds of Nepalese people. This is often described as anti-India rhetoric by a section of India’s elites.
One small section of people in Nepal also portrays India as a ‘regional hegemon’ for their petty political interests, while a section of Indians accuse Nepal of playing the ‘China card’. But in general, this is not true and it does not represent the overal perception and opinion of all people of both the countries. The majority of Nepalis have a friendly and positive attitude towards India and want closer and cooperative relations. A large section of the Indian population also has friendly and very positive feelings towards Nepal. It is the politics stupid that sometimes seeks to create barrier between Nepali and Indian people for personal and partisan interest in both the countries.
Similarly, India definitely has its concerns in Nepal, which Kathmandu should address. Nepal cannot and should not play any card against India, about which Nepal needs to assure its neighbours. Thus, all issues and problems between Nepal and India need to be discussed in a frank and friendly manner and solutions should be sought accordingly instead of sweeping the problems under the rug. The differences and disputes on certain issues should by no means be allowed to impede the overall relations and cooperation between these two neighbours.
Nepal and India are possessed of a multitude of resources and have diverse areas of cooperation. Both the countries now need to seriously explore the areas of cooperation and work jointly for their common benefit. Now Prime Minister Shah is visiting India with the enormous goodwill of the Nepali people. India, after Modi rose to power, also adopted a ‘neighbourhood first policy’ and Indian Prime Minister Modi, during his visit to Nepal in 2014, announced the HIT (Highways, Information ways and Transmission way) formula focusing on connectivity between Nepal and India. However, this is yet to be realised in practice; instead, the high tone set during Modi’s visit reached its nadir during India’s fourth blockade in 2015. Now the situation has changed and a better atmosphere of cooperation has emerged. PM Shah’s visit is expected to further promote this atmosphere.
PM Shah’s visit is expected to reset and elevate the level of relations between these closest neighbours. But it depends on the level of preparations and home work. The primary objective of the visit is building an atmosphere of trust between the two governments and understanding the positions of one another on all issues. All accumulated problems cannot be resolved in one visit but it would definitely set a new tone in the relations, facilitating to resolve outstanding issues in a gradual manner and on a priority basis. Being a smaller land-locked country surrounded by giant neighbours, it is natural for Nepal to be extra-sensitive about its sovereignty, which big neighbours need to understand. It is high time that India respond accordingly to dispel Nepal’s apprehension.
National interest
Similarly, Nepal also needs to understand India’s sensitivities and accordingly address them so far as they do not clash with its national interests.Despite India espousing a ‘neighbourhood first policy’ with priority to relations with neighbouring countries like Nepal, this is yet to be seen in real practice owing to perhaps traditional bureaucracy that appears to be still influenced by the old Nehru-Gandhi era’s mindset. Modi’s India needs to come out of this old mentality in dealing with small neighbours, especially Nepal.
PM Balendra Shah definitely seeks to reset and elevate the level of relations with India. New Delhi, too, is expected to come up with a newer approach and a bigger heart to address the sensitivities of Nepal and begin afresh to resolve all issues through diplomatic negotiation and in a gradual manner. In this lies the broader interests of both the countries. PM Shah’s upcoming visit is, thus, expected to prove a new era of cooperation with greater harmonization between these two closest neighbours.
(The author is a former chief editor of this daily and a former ambassador. lamsalyubanath@gmail.com)
Comments
Post a Comment